Skip to footer
Shop All Cotton Cordell

Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper

Shop All Cotton Cordell

Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper

$8.99 - $9.00
Cordell Pencil Popper Bone 4.5"
In Stock: 10+
Price: $8.99
  • Color: Bone Stock # C64BONE
  • Short Lengths: 4.5"
Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Bone 6"
In Stock: 10+
Price: $9.00
  • Color: Bone Stock # C66BONE
  • Short Lengths: 6"
Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Chrome/Black 6"
In Stock: 8
Price: $9.00
  • Color: Chrome/Black Stock # C6604
  • Short Lengths: 6"
Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Chrome/Blue 6"
In Stock: 6
Price: $9.00
  • Color: Chrome/Blue Stock # C6606
  • Short Lengths: 6"
Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Pearl Yellow 6"
In Stock: 5
Price: $9.00
  • Color: Pearl Yellow Stock # C66PYRG
  • Short Lengths: 6"
Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Pearl/Blue 6"
In Stock: 8
Price: $9.00
  • Color: Pearl/Blue Stock # C6620
  • Short Lengths: 6"
Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Bone 7"
In Stock: 5
Price: $9.00
  • Color: Bone Stock # C67BONE
  • Short Lengths: 7"
Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Chrome/Black 7"
In Stock: 5
Price: $9.00
  • Color: Chrome/Black Stock # C6704
  • Short Lengths: 7"
Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Chrome/Blue 7"
In Stock: 6
Price: $9.00
  • Color: Chrome/Blue Stock # C6706
  • Short Lengths: 7"
Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Pearl/Blue 7"
In Stock: 6
Price: $9.00
  • Color: Pearl/Blue Stock # C6720
  • Short Lengths: 7"
Cordell Pencil Popper Chrome Black Back 4.5"
In Stock: 7
Price: $8.99
  • Color: Chrome/Black Stock # C6404
  • Short Lengths: 4.5"
Cordell Pencil Popper Chrome Blue Back 4.5"
In Stock: 7
Price: $8.99
  • Color: Chrome/Blue Stock # C6406
  • Short Lengths: 4.5"

WARNING: Cancer and Reproductive Harm - www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.

Free return shipping is available for all orders shipped within the 48 contiguous United States. These orders will include a complimentary pre-paid UPS Ground return label in the box when the order is delivered. If you use the pre-paid return label provided, please allow 7-10 business days for the return package to arrive back at Tackle Warehouse.

Orders shipped to international, APO/FPO, Alaskan or Hawaiian addresses or U.S. territories are not eligible for the free return shipping offer. Drop Ship and Oversized Items are not eligible for the free return shipping offer.

Please use our Returns & Exchange form found on the back of your printed invoice. If you don't have your original invoice you can download our Tackle Warehouse Return Form.

Contact us with any questions or concerns!

Phone: 1.800.300.4916
Email: info@tacklewarehouse.com

Tackle Warehouse wants you to be completely satisfied with your purchase. Items can be returned at any point in new condition within 365-days of the original invoice date.

Products returned in new, store-bought condition are eligible for exchange, refund, or Tackle Warehouse store credit for the full value of your purchase.

Please note that while we want you to be happy with your purchases, an excessive number of returns within a twelve-month period may limit your eligibility for refund or store credit.

Products returned beyond 365-days from the original invoice date or that are unable to be returned to stock may be eligible for store credit at the sole discretion of Tackle Warehouse.

Original shipping charges are non-refundable.

Used baits & tackle are not eligible for return.

Phone: 1.800.300.4916
Email: info@tacklewarehouse.com

Overview

A long time standard of coastal surf fishermen, the Cotton Cordell's Pencil Popper is designed to deliver super-long casts. Within the tail section of each Pencil Popper  is an added weight that forces the lure to sit 'tail down' creating a bobbing target. All Pencil Poppers are designed for a relatively heavy line and are equipped with super-strong, rust resistant hooks.

Cotton Cordell WeightClassHooks
Pencil Popper 4.5"3/4ozTopwater#2
Pencil Popper 6"1ozTopwater1/0
Pencil Popper 7"2ozTopwater3/0

Upgrade Your Treble Hooks!

Customer Reviews

Previous Feedback  

Comments: I love Pencil Poppers, and have caught more stripers, blues, largemouth and pike on the 6" Cordell Pencil Popper than any other topwater hard bait. BUT since Pradco took over, the quality of the hooks has gone way downhill. They just don't hold a point, and they get bent out of shape too easily on big fish.

From: Rich: 10/28/22

Comments: The new 4.5" size is the bomb! Casts like a rocket and walks easier than just about any other model out there. Don't waste your money on fancier foreign top waters, this one works just as good if not better! If you fish clear water, try the blue nose model...

From: Unknown: Little Rock, AR 8/29/19

Comments: This lure has been around since the 1940's the original was wood. It flat out catches monsters. I'm loving the new 4.5" size !! Thanks Pradco.

From: John: Lakeland, FL 8/17/19

Comments: Dont waste money with copy cats that are 4 to 5 x the price. This lure just works! Easy to work, lots of noise big splash too for those slightly windy days working it for stripers!  Cast a mile! The only down side is the color selection.

From: CA

Comments: the original. every pencil popper today is actually a clone of this bait. its been around forever, with good reason. it catches lots of fish, especially stripers.

Comments: a clone of the ima big stick,ata uch cheaper price.this lure whileit looks bland,boring and like not much,lemme tell u im not sure what it exactly is about it but fish LOVE to hit,kill and destroy this thing.its a real fun bait to use and watch the water boiling strikes.

From: Stevieboy: Chicago

Comments:This lure is a sleeper. The originals were used in the surf for stripers, but now with the lighter smaller versions, the fresh water fisherman can use them for topwater bass fishing. I call them the frugal mans gunfish by luckycraft. I don't say there superior but thier close. Also, the price is great. No lure on the market walks as easily or cast and hooks any better. If you give them a try I'm sure you will agree. Bait casting outfits with a 7ft. medium action rod and 17lb. to 25lb. mono works for me----

From:Wes: Salinas, CA

Back to Top